Pet Sitting 101: Strategies for Managing Multiple Dogs

Written By Ally Kim

Managing Multiple Dogs During Pet Sitting

Pet sitting multiple dogs can be a rewarding experience, but it comes with its unique set of challenges. Whether you're a seasoned pet sitter/pet owners or new to the role, understanding how to manage different dog personalities is crucial. This guide offers practical strategies to ensure a harmonious environment for all furry friends involved.

Understanding Dog Dynamics

Recognizing Individual Personalities Each dog has its temperament. Some are playful and energetic, while others may be more reserved. Observing and understanding each dog's behavior helps in anticipating reactions and preventing conflicts.

The Impact of Desexing Desexed dogs often exhibit fewer dominance-related behaviors. However, interactions between desexed and non-desexed dogs require careful monitoring, as hormonal differences can influence behavior.

Preparing for the Sit

Pre-Sit Meet and Greet Introduce the dogs in a neutral environment before the actual sitting begins. This helps in assessing compatibility and easing initial tensions.

Gathering Essential Information Collect details about each dog's dietary needs, medical history, and behavioral quirks. Having emergency contacts and vet information on hand is also essential.

Establishing a Routine

Consistent Feeding and Walk Schedules Maintain regular feeding times and walk schedules. Consistency helps in reducing anxiety and establishing a sense of normalcy.

Designated Play and Rest Times Balance active play with rest periods. Structured schedules prevent overstimulation and promote better behavior.

Managing Play and Preventing Conflicts

Supervised Play Sessions Always monitor playtime. Watch for signs of overexcitement or aggression, and intervene when necessary to prevent escalation.

Addressing Humping Behavior Humping can be a sign of dominance, excitement, or stress. Redirect the behavior with commands or distractions, and ensure both dogs have adequate exercise and mental stimulation.

Creating a Safe Environment

Separate Spaces Provide individual resting areas for each dog. Using baby gates or crates can help manage space and give dogs their own territory.

Safe Toys and Activities Offer appropriate toys to prevent resource guarding. Engage dogs in mentally stimulating activities to keep them occupied and reduce unwanted behaviors.

Handling Common Scenarios

Scenario 1: Two Energetic Young Dogs

  • Structured Play Sessions: Plan specific times for active play like fetch or tug-of-war to burn off energy. Keep playtime short and intense—10-15 minutes at a time with breaks in between.

  • Obedience During Play: Use basic commands like “sit”, “stay”, and “leave it” during games to create structure.

  • Calm-Down Cues: Teach dogs a “settle” cue with a comfy spot and reward them when they calm down.

  • Separate Timeouts: If play escalates into roughhousing, separate the dogs briefly to let them cool down.

Scenario 2: One Dog Exhibiting Dominant Behavior

  • Watch for Triggers: Note situations that cause mounting, growling, or resource guarding—typically food, toys, or proximity to people.

  • Neutralize Resources: Feed dogs in separate areas and remove high-value toys unless supervised.

  • Redirect and Reward: Use commands like “off” or “enough” to interrupt unwanted behavior. Immediately redirect with a toy or trick, then reward the new behavior.

  • Short-Term Separation: Use baby gates to keep dogs apart during high-energy times until mutual respect is established.

Scenario 3: Dogs with Different Energy Levels

  • Tailored Exercise Plans: Walk high-energy dogs for longer or schedule an extra short outing. Provide mental puzzles (e.g., snuffle mats, treat toys) for calmer dogs.

  • Parallel Activities: Let the energetic dog play with toys while the quieter dog relaxes beside you. Avoid forcing them to match pace.

  • Respect Boundaries: Provide the less energetic dog with quiet retreats—like a bed in a separate room—to decompress when needed.

  • Individual Bonding Time: Give each dog one-on-one attention to avoid jealousy or overstimulation.

Communication with Dog Owners

Regular Updates Keep owners informed with photos and messages. Discuss any behavioral concerns promptly to ensure transparency and trust.

Post-Sit Feedback Share observations about dog interactions and provide suggestions for future sits. This feedback can be invaluable for owners and future sitters.

Joining the Pawshare Club Community

Peer Support Dog Sitting: Save Money, Worry Less, Connect More. At Pawshare Club, we connect Melbourne dog lovers to swap dog sitting and dog walks with a simple, fair point system — no cash needed, just community care and genuine connections.

  • Save Money: Eliminate traditional pet-sitting fees by exchanging sits and walks with other trusted members.

  • Worry Less: Know your dog is with someone who truly cares. All members are part of a vetted, supportive network.

  • Connect More: Make lasting friendships with fellow dog lovers in your neighborhood.

Ready to enhance your pet-sitting experience? Join the Pawshare Club today for support, resources, and a community that understands your journey.

Quick Checklist

Ally Kim
Next

The Ultimate Dog Sitting Swaps Checklist